Light bulb We updated the website and resources for you. Send Feedback

Search Console: Fix “Alternate page with proper canonical tag” Error in Page Indexing

Published 15 Dec, 2022 Modified 23 Dec, 2022 Read in 2m 59s Viewed 6.564K times

Unlike other page indexing issues, alternate page with proper canonical tag is not strictly an issue. However, you still need to fix it if it is thrown due to human error or URL anomalies.

Experience Based

This guide is helpful to understand the meaning of alternate page with proper canonical tag issue in search console.

What is alternate page with proper canonical tag error?

Alternate page with proper canonical tag error in Google Search Console is due to the any or all of the following reasons: –

  • the crawled page is an AMP-version of its original/canonical page
  • or the crawled page is mobile-only version of its desktop or original page
  • or the page is desktop version of its canonical mobile version which is already indexed
  • or you have defined the crawled page as alternate or another indexed page

Since Google has already indexed the original or canonical version of the crawled page, it adds that page under the error ‘Alternate page with proper canonical tag’.

It means you have clearly defined the crawled page as an alternate for its original one. Normally this is done by specifying an alternate meta tag on the canonical and canonical meta tag on the alternate page.

What to do if you need to index the alternate version of a page?

We recommend to prefer indexing of only original page while define alternate in the headers. Since the content is same on all versions while the view might be enhanced for devices, regions, or performance, it is recommended to make the original page as canonical for all of its alternates.

When the user visits the page, the right alternate version is automatically picked based on your configuration and definitions.

Therefore, if you try to index both URLs by removing canonical tag from the alternate page, it will fall under duplicate content within your domain. Don’t do it.

What should we do with alternate pages with proper canonical tags?

Since this is an intentional act of defining alternate pages from an original one, you should be doing nothing in this case. However, we recommend to check the sample of pages falling under this reason/issue in search console. If the alternate page is correct and pointing to correct canonical, leave it and don’t worry. If you find any URL anomaly, correct it and mark validate the fix.

Remember that alternate pages created for different languages are not detected by Google. This is because those pages are served to user after a detection of their region when they are on the website. If you’re using alternate tag for language pages, Google may detect it and it is okay as long as you have defined proper canonical tag.

Also make sure that the canonical versions (of the crawled alternate pages) are not having any 404 errors, server errors, or more issues as listed in page indexing issues.

Will my website shall be penalized due to ‘Alternate page with proper canonical tag’ errors?

No. Since this technique is the right practice to handle duplicate content, Google simply ignores the pages falling under this issue. There is no penalty imposed due to a small or big number of alternate pages with proper canonical tag. Just keep building high quality and useful original pages.

How to handle alternate page with proper canonical tag error for AMP pages?

Since AMP pages are valid duplicated pages for the original content, it is likely that you see ‘alternate page with proper canonical tag’ error for all of your AMP page versions. It is okay to have it and it doesn’t penalize your website. This is not a strict issue or need any fix. It is just like Google now knows you have an AMP-version of your canonical/original page and Google may recommend the original one when needed.